Oklahoma State upsets Florida, 2-1

Florida pitcher Kelly Barnhill. [Brad McClenny/Staff photographer/file]

Special to Gatorsports.com

OKLAHOMA CITY — Florida senior All-American pitcher Kelly Barnhill struck out nine and allowed only two hits to Oklahoma State in Thursday’s opening day of the Women’s College World Series. Unfortunately for Barnhill and the Gators, the two hits were home runs by Cowgirls senior pitcher Samantha Show in the 2-1 loss.

The fifth-seeded Gators (49-17) will now have to battle out of the losers’ bracket to make the championship series that starts Monday. It starts at 2:30 p.m. ET Saturday with an elimination game against eight-seeded Alabama (57-9), which lost to top-seeded Oklahoma 3-2 in Thursday night’s late game. 13th seed Oklahoma State (45-15) will play Oklahoma (55-3) Friday night.

“We didn’t have very many productive at-bats,” UF coach Tim Walton said. “Our outs, they made a couple nice plays defensively, but our outs just weren’t very good. You can have good outs, be productive with your outs, move runners along. We didn’t have that. That’s the biggest key. Six hits, but yet the 21 outs, how many of them were productive? There weren’t very many of them.”

Show (22-8), the game’s second batter, belted a homer in the first inning.

The Gators tied it in the second on Jordan Roberts’ solo home run, her ninth of the season.

Show then gave the Cowgirls the lead with her 20th home run of the season with a blast in the sixth.

While Barnhill (34-13), who after Show’s home run in the first, retired 14 of the next 16 batters faced over the next four innings, pitched well enough to win, the Gators didn’t do much to help her, going 0 for 8 with a runner in scoring position.

“I think more than anything, it’s just missing a spot,” Barnhill said of her night. “I missed two pitches to their best hitter on the team, so…”

The Gators’ best scoring opportunity came in the bottom of the seventh when Sophia Reynoso and Roberts opened with singles, but three consecutive groundouts sealed UF’s fate.

“I just think we need to flush it and just be more competitive,” UF senior Amanda Lorenz said. “We have nothing to lose. I think the day off will be good for us, just to focus on the Gators, on what we can do better to be more successful next game.”

Show, who allowed six hits, became the first pitcher to homer twice in a WCWS game.

Show transferred to Oklahoma State from Texas A&M. Florida coach Tim Walton remembers the previous version of Show and thinks this one is better.

“I think she’s a whole entirely different person,” he said. “You look at everything about her — it’s different, better in every sense of the word. She’s just done a good job all the way around. It almost looks like she’s completely comfortable in who she is right now competing both offensively and defensively.”

Oklahoma State, which upset defending national champion Florida State in the Super Regionals and is the lowest-seeded team in the World Series field, needs one more win to reach the semifinals.

Notes: Amanda Lorenz, Kelly Barnhill and Kendyl Lindaman each were selected as NFCA All-Americans. Lorenz became only the second UF player in program history to be named an NFCA All-American all four years – Hannah Rogers (2011-’14) was the only other player to achieve the feat. Lorenz holds three first team selections (2017-’19) and a third team selection (2016) over her career. Barnhill was named to the second team and Lindaman to the third team. … Barnhill (358) is approaching the UF single-season strikeout record. Stacey Nelson holds (2006-’09) the mark with 363 strikeouts.

At ASA Hall of Fame Stadium

Oklahoma City

All Times EDT

Double Elimination; x-if necessary


Arizona 3, Washington 1, 8 innings

UCLA 7, Minnesota 2

Oklahoma State 2, Florida 1

Oklahoma 3, Alabama 2


Game 5 — Arizona (48-12) vs. UCLA (52-6), 7 p.m.

Game 6 — Oklahoma State (45-15) vs. Oklahoma (55-3), 9:30 p.m.


Game 7 — Washington (50-8) vs. Minnesota (46-13), Noon

Game 8 — Florida (49-17) vs. Alabama (57-9), 2:30 p.m.

Game 9 — Game 6 loser vs. Game 7 winner, 7 p.m.

Game 10 — Game 5 loser vs. Game 8 winner, 9:30 p.m.


Game 11 — Game 5 winner vs. Game 9 winner, 1 p.m.

Game 12 — Game 6 winner vs. Game 10 winner, 3:30 p.m.

x-Game 13 — Game 5 winner vs. Game 9 winner, 7 p.m.

x-Game 14 — Game 6 winner vs. Game 10 winner, 9:30 p.m.

NOTE: If only one game is necessary, it will be played at 7 p.m.

Championship Series


Monday: Teams TBD, 7:30 p.m.

Tuesday: Teams TBD, 8:30 p.m.

x-Wednesday: Teams TBD, 8:30 p.m.


  1. Hard fought game tonight, but a little disappointing when you help your opponent beat you. The offense again forced KB to have to be perfect, and two poorly executed pitching sequences to Show kept that from happening. Show still had to hit the pitches, though, so she deserves the credit.

    Also wonder what would’ve happened in the bottom of the 7th if Coach Walton had called for Caraway to bunt the runners over with two on and nobody out. Matthews ground-out to second might have scored the tying run. Still softball left to be played, so Go Gators!!!

  2. right on the mark, Joe. Caraway should have bunted. period. The grounder would have tied it up.
    Agree that this was not an upset. OSU took out the national champs and are hot. Give all the credit in the world to our girls. They have given it all they have and are maxed out against the best pitching in the country. When they are done in OKC, whenever that is, they should be nothing but proud of themselves.