Thatcher song joins list of censored tunes

John Lydon performs with The Sex Pistols. The group's song “God Save the Queen” was banned by the BBC. (The Associated Press/File)

Published: Saturday, April 13, 2013 at 6:01 a.m.
Last Modified: Friday, April 12, 2013 at 5:45 p.m.

A 70-year-old song is giving the BBC a headache.

The radio and television broadcaster has agonized over whether to play Ding Dong! The Witch is Dead, a tune from The Wizard of Oz that is being driven up the charts by opponents of Margaret Thatcher as a mocking memorial to the late British prime minister.

A compromise announced Friday the BBC will play part of Ding Dong! but not the whole song on its chart-countdown radio show is unlikely to end the recriminations

This is not the first time Britains national broadcaster, which is nicknamed Auntie for its we-know-whats-good-for-you attitude, has been caught in a bind about whether to ban a song on grounds of language, politics or taste.

Heres a look at some previous censorship scandals:

Sex, drugs and double entendres

The 1960s and 70s saw several songs barred from airplay for sex or drug references, including The Beatles A Day in the Life, for a fleeting and implicit reference to smoking marijuana.

For The Kinks 1970 hit Lola, the trouble was not sex or drugs, but product placement. The line you drink champagne and it tastes just like Coca-Cola fell afoul of the public broadcasters rule banning corporate plugs. The brand name had to be replaced with cherry cola before the song could be aired.

The BBC frequently has been targeted by self-appointed moral guardians, most famously the late anti-smut activist Mary Whitehouse, who campaigned for decades against what she saw as pornography and permissiveness.

In 1972, Whitehouse got the BBC to ban the video for Alice Coopers Schools Out for allegedly being a bad influence on children. The controversy helped the song reach No. 1 in the charts, and Cooper sent Whitehouse flowers. He later said she had given his band publicity we couldnt buy.

But Whitehouses campaign to get Chuck Berrys My Ding-a-Ling banned on grounds of indecency was unsuccessful. The BBCs chief at the time told Whitehouse that, while the songs title could be seen as a double entendre, we believe that the innuendo is, at worst, on the level of seaside postcards or music hall humor.

Political pitfalls

Paul McCartney may now be the cuddly elder statesman of pop, but his first single with the band Wings, Give Ireland Back to the Irish, caused a storm.

Written after the 1972 killing of 13 Irish nationalist protesters by British troops on Bloody Sunday in Londonderry, the single was barred from all TV and radio airplay in Britain but reached No. 1 in Ireland, where it was not banned.

The Sex Pistols God Save the Queen with its opening refrain God save the queen, the fascist regime was released in 1977, the year of Queen Elizabeth IIs Silver Jubilee.

The BBC banned it on the grounds of gross bad taste, and some stores refused to stock it, to the delight of the punk band, whose anti-establishment credentials were cemented by the controversy.

It remains one of the most famous songs never to reach No. 1 on the charts. It hit No. 2, but was kept from the top spot by Rod Stewarts I Dont Want to Talk About It.

Punk fans sensed a conspiracy, and debate still rages over whether the Pistols song really did reach No. 1.

Buoyed by a ban

God Save the Queen and Schools Out arent the only examples of how an airplay ban can boost a song.

In 1984, BBC DJ Mike Read pulled the plug on Relax by Frankie Goes to Hollywood midway through its first broadcast, calling the thumping, lyrically suggestive song obscene.

Though it wasnt officially banned, the BBC did not play it. The controversy helped push the song by a then-unknown band up the charts, where it stayed in the No. 1 spot for five weeks.

Censors and sensibilities

While the moral panics of past eras can seem ridiculous, this weeks Thatcher controversy shows that the central issue which is worse, censorship or causing offense? is both complex and unresolved.

In 2007, the BBC censored the Christmas song Fairytale of New York by The Pogues, which was first released 20 years earlier, by dubbing out an anti-gay slur. Some listeners were outraged, but others, including gay rights campaigner Peter Tatchell, said the BBC had been right to remove the word.

Reader comments posted to this article may be published in our print edition. All rights reserved. This copyrighted material may not be re-published without permission. Links are encouraged.

▲ Return to Top

Find Us on Facebook