German warrants issued for CIA agents
Published: Thursday, February 1, 2007 at 6:01 a.m.
Last Modified: Wednesday, January 31, 2007 at 10:51 p.m.
BERLIN — German prosecutors said Wednesday that they have issued arrest warrants for 13 suspected CIA agents who allegedly abducted a German citizen in an apparent anti-terrorist operation gone wrong.
It was Washington's second European ally to seek the arrest of purported CIA agents for spiriting away a terrorism suspect. Italian prosecutors want to question 25 agents and one other American in the alleged kidnapping of an Egyptian cleric suspected of terrorism.
Munich prosecutor Christian Schmidt-Sommerfeld told The Associated Press that warrants in the latest case were issued in the last few days. He said the unidentified agents were sought on suspicion of wrongfully imprisoning Khaled al-Masri and causing him serious bodily harm.
Al-Masri, a German citizen of Lebanese descent, says he was detained in December 2003 at the Serbian-Macedonian border and then flown by the CIA to a jail in Afghanistan, where he was abused. He says he was let go in Albania five months later and told he had been seized in a case of mistaken identity.
Rights activists have seized on al-Masri's story and other cases to demand that the U.S. stop "extraordinary rendition" — moving terrorism suspects to third countries where they could face torture. Some European governments have been accused of winking at the practice.
Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice and other U.S. officials have declined to address al-Masri's case. However, German Chancellor Angela Merkel has said the Bush administration acknowledged making a mistake with al-Masri.
Germany's government refused to comment on the arrest warrants, as did the CIA. The State Department's deputy spokesman, Tom Casey, said only that the U.S. would review the allegations.
NDR television released a list of 11 men and two women reportedly named in the warrants. It said three had been contacted by its reporters and had refused comment.
The prosecutor's office refused to confirm the list, while revealing the suspects' real names weren't known.
"The personal details contained in the arrest warrants are, according to our current knowledge, aliases of CIA agents," Schmidt-Sommerfeld said in a statement. "Further investigation will, among other things, concentrate on trying to determine the clear identities of the suspects."
Al-Masri's attorney, Manfred Gnjidic, said the issuing of the arrest warrants was "a very important step in the rehabilitation" of his client. "It shows us that we were right in putting our trust in the German authorities and the German prosecutors," he told reporters.
Prosecutors were led to the suspects after receiving a list in December 2005 of possible people involved in al-Masri's detention compiled by a Spanish journalist from sources within Spain's Civil Guard, a paramilitary police unit, Schmidt-Sommerfeld said.
He said Spanish authorities then provided help and prosecutors were able to pursue an investigation against "concrete persons."
Schmidt-Sommerfeld said tips were also received from others, including prosecutors in Milan, Italy, and Dick Marty, a Swiss senator who led a Council of Europe inquiry into purported CIA "extraordinary rendition" flights. The prosecutor did not give any details on the tips.
The CIA agents are suspected of flying aboard a Boeing 737 from the Spanish island of Palma de Mallorca in January 2004 to pick up al-Masri from Macedonian authorities, another prosecutor, August Stern, said.
ARD television said last year investigators were working from passport photocopies made by a hotel where the suspects stayed, but Stern said he could not confirm that or other details.
The Justice Department has declined to provide Munich prosecutors assistance, citing legal proceedings involving al-Masri in the United States.
Al-Masri has asked a federal appeals court in Richmond, Va., to reinstate a lawsuit against the CIA seeking compensation. A judge dismissed the suit last May, ruling that a trial could harm national security by revealing details about CIA activities.
The German government has said it learned of the case only after al-Masri's release. In late 2005, Interior Minister Wolfgang Schaeuble said the then-U.S. ambassador to Germany had told his predecessor, Otto Schily, about it May 31, 2004.
Schaeuble said Ambassador Dan Coats provided no details of al-Masri's treatment, but told Schily that "one had apologized to him (al-Masri) and agreed (on) confidentiality and paid him a sum of money."
Gnjidic, al-Masri's lawyer, has said his client denies receiving either an apology or money.
Reader comments posted to this article may be published in our print edition. All rights reserved. This copyrighted material may not be re-published without permission. Links are encouraged.
Comments are currently unavailable on this article