Jurors hear opposite tales in Stewart case


Published: Wednesday, January 28, 2004 at 6:01 a.m.
Last Modified: Wednesday, January 28, 2004 at 1:49 a.m.

NEW YORK - Martha Stewart sold stock based on ''a secret tip'' that no one else had, then told an avalanche of lies to save her reputation and enormous fortune, a federal prosecutor said Tuesday in laying out the case against the homemaking queen.

Stewart's attorney insisted the case was based on ''speculation, surmise and guesswork.''

The jury of eight women and four men listened to three hours of opening statements that outlined starkly different portrayals of Stewart's sale of nearly 4,000 shares in the biotechnology company ImClone Systems on Dec. 27, 2001.

The government contends that Stewart, on her way to a vacation in Mexico, was tipped that ImClone founder Sam Waksal was trying to dump his own shares, then ordered her own shares sold.

Assistant U.S. Attorney Karen Patton Seymour said Stewart then conspired with her stockbroker, Peter Bacanovic, to tell a series of cover-up lies about the sale.

''The reason that Martha Stewart dumped her shares is because she was told a secret,'' Seymour said. ''A secret tip that no other investors in ImClone had.''

Stewart was almost motionless as the arguments unfolded in front of her, resting her chin on her hand and occasionally tapping an index finger against her lips.

She faces as much as 30 years in prison on charges that include obstruction of justice and securities fraud, but likely would get a far lighter penalty if convicted. Bacanovic also is charged with five counts and faces 25 years.

Attorneys for Stewart and Bacanovic aimed to convince jurors that the two defendants had done nothing out of the ordinary for a diligent broker and responsible client, arguing that they had decided six days before the ImClone sale to get rid of the stock if it fell to $60.

Waksal later admitted he was tipped that federal regulators were about to issue a negative report on ImClone's only drug, the cancer treatment Erbitux. That report sent the stock plummeting. Waksal later pleaded guilty to securities fraud and has begun serving a prison term of more than seven years.

Bacanovic knew it was against the policy of his firm, Merrill Lynch & Co., to pass information about one client's trades to another, Seymour said. But, the prosecutor said, he made sure word of Waksal's sale was passed along to Stewart.

''He knew he couldn't do it,'' she said. ''But he didn't want his friend Martha Stewart sitting on a stock that was about to be obliterated by bad news.'' Stewart attorney Robert Morvillo pointed out that 7 million shares of rapidly falling ImClone were sold on the day Stewart sold hers. She avoided $45,673 in losses on the shares by selling before the bad news was made public. Bacanovic attorney Richard Strassberg said the broker made a paltry $450 on the sale.

Reader comments posted to this article may be published in our print edition. All rights reserved. This copyrighted material may not be re-published without permission. Links are encouraged.

Comments are currently unavailable on this article

▲ Return to Top